patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Sunny
31° F Hi:39  Lo:32
 

Parks and Recreation, Hoboken-style

Public dialogue over Project Play gets momentarily heated, but most people at the meeting support plans to upgrade playgrounds in Church Square Park.

 

Correction appended.

Church Square Park was the topic of heated discussion Saturday afternoon when about 35 residents gathered during a public meeting  to discuss proposed upgrades to some of its playgrounds.

The park is known in Hoboken for having served a diverse range of purposes throughout its 200-year history. 

The meeting began calmly enough with Zabrina Stoffel and Regina Gannon, the two residents spearheading Project Play, introducing their plans to a group of roughly 35 residents that included council members Peter Cunningham and Carol Marsh, Hudson County freeholder Anthony Romano and Assemblyman Ruben Ramos.

"This is a concept meeting," Stoffel began, noting that the designs she and Gannon would be unveiling are subject to community input and, therefore, change. "Our guiding principles are to replace the current equipment with safe, fun, and innovative equipment using environmentally sustainable materials," said Stoffel.

Stoffel went on to give residents in attendance background on how Project Play reached its design decisions, saying that the group conducted research by visiting parks throughout the area, county and state and by polling parents and kids on what types of improvements they'd like to see made. Stoffel said security, aesthetics,  community building and a design that is in accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act were the chief priorities that influenced the concept the group has developed.

The meeting was arranged by Environmental Services Director Jennifer Wenson Maier, who worked as the director of public works and urban development in Plainfield, NJ, before being appointed in Hoboken on March 1. Prior to the meeting, Maier said that she has extensive experience working on park renovations and enjoys such work immensely.

"These are the most fun projects that I work on," Maier said without the slightest hint of irony. Little did Maier know that about 45 minutes later she'd be almost nose-to-nose with a resident in a heated exchange, threatening to shut down the meeting.

Stoffel and Gannon conducted a show-and-tell demonstration, presenting examples of various RePlay TimberForm materials, made from post-consumer recycled plastic. The duo also introduced playground concept designs prepared by Columbia Cascade, an Oregon-based company that specializes in landscape architecture.

Stoffel explained that Project Play plans to fund the upgrades with money raised through government grants, donations and corporate sponsorship, while keeping the project nearly cost-free to the city. Companies or individuals who donate to the cause, she said, would have their names displayed on engraved bricks or on plaques affixed to benches.

The floor was then opened for questions from residents, where several residents voiced concerns and outright disapproval of Project Play's plan. The majority of attendants expressed enthusiasm and gratitude to Stoffel and Gannon.

Perhaps Project Play's harshest critic, longtime Hoboken resident Mary Ondrejka detailed a litany of problems she has with the plans, ranging from the proposed recycled plastic materials to the proposed new swings not being designed with adults in mind.

Providing one of the more amusing moments of the meeting, Ondrejka declared that she likes to use the swings at Church Square Park and that she's not the only adult who uses them. "That design is not good for adults," said Ondrejka, gesturing toward Project Play's swing set diagram.

"You shouldn't be going on the swings," Kate Gillian, a 28-year-old pre-school teacher at The Brandt School and Hoboken resident, shot back at Ondrejka. "They're for kids."

People's attitudes toward the proposal seemed to be inextricably tied to whether or not they have children. Ondrejka was joined in her opposition by fellow longtime residents Dan Tumpson and Cheryl Fallick, neither of whom have children.

Tumpson disapproved of the plan for additional fencing around the playground areas, increases to the amount of artificial lighting and corporate sponsorship. "Kids won't be in the park when lights are on," said Tumpson of Project Play's contention that the playground is inadequately lit at night. "That doesn't make sense."

Hudson County Freeholder and Hoboken police captain Romano interjected, saying that lighting is necessary at night because without the lighting, the park's security cameras would be rendered useless.

About seven people opposed the initiative, one of whom described the designs as "very unimaginative" and "very mediocre." Another resident, who said he is a parent, also opposed the plan.

But, those who have young children overwhelmingly showed support for Project Play, mainly because they believe the improvements will contribute to making Hoboken a city where young families will choose to stay, instead of moving to the suburbs.

Shan Gettens, 38, the mother of a 5-year-old and a 3-year-old, said she and her husband have lived in Hoboken for 10 years and they want to continue living here. She said improvements to Church Square Park and other city parks would be an enticement for her to stay.

As the meeting looked to be winding down, one resident praised Stoffel and Gannon for working to make Hoboken more family-friendly, which drew a round of applause. But Fallick bluntly contended that families with young children aren't the only interest group in town.

Maier approached Fallick and told her to stop speaking out of turn. The two women began shouting at each other and the usually soft-spoken Maier roared, "I'll shut this meeting down right now if this continues."

Emotions became so heated during the dustup that Peter Cunningham used his arms to create a makeshift fence between Maier and Fallick. 

Tzveta Ivanova, 31, who moved here almost five years ago from Bulgaria liked what she heard. She and her husband have 3-year-old twin daughters and had been entertaining the idea of moving to Battery Park City in Manhattan, but instead have decided to buy an apartment in Hoboken.

Ivanova wasn't aware of Project Play until yesterday's meeting and she applauded Stoffel and Gannon for taking proactive measures to improve the park. Moreover, she was unfazed by the idea of corporate sponsorship to help fund the upgrades.

"If that's the price to pay for new equipment," said Ivanova, "that's a small price."

Yesterday's meeting was not an officially sanctioned meeting, just the first step in the public hearing process, Maier said. There will be a public meeting held at night that is advertised with at least 30 days notice prior to the meeting in accordance with the Open Public Meetings Act. Meanwhile, Maier said, anyone is welcome to work up a conceptual design and submit it to the director's office.

Afterwards, Stoffel said she viewed the meeting as moving one step closer to Project Play realizing its goal.

A previous version of this article misspelled Cheryl Fallick and Mary Ondrejka's names.

Journey

9:34 am on Monday, May 24, 2010

Some of the non-parents and parents alike are concerned that the park is becoming less diverse. More stuff for kids and less space for adults.

I want my daughter to grow up seeing seniors at the park. I and my daughter, the little blond toddler were both at the meeting.

Log in to reply

FAP

11:02 am on Monday, May 24, 2010

There is a concern that the park is being transitioned away from open general space to fenced in activity spaces. I haven't seen the citizen plan that is being put forward but if it converts existing open active space to designed activity space I can understand the opposition.

A balance can and needs to be struck allowing for the most use by the greatest number of people. I think everyone in the discussion has good intentions so I have confidence this balance can be stuck.

Log in to reply

Journey

12:18 pm on Monday, May 24, 2010

The plan is updated the playground equipment in existing locations, namely the swings and structure on the southern side of the park. The have hopes of also updating the large structure in the center.

Log in to reply

FAP

12:42 pm on Monday, May 24, 2010

"The have hopes of also updating the large structure in the center."

You mean the gazebo? What are their "hopes"?

For the record this is a citizen group, well meaning I'm sure, that is not appointed, regognized or empowered by the municipal, county, state or federal government. As such I don't beleive there are any regonized procedures to vett their suggestions before they are presented to the public.

But good ideas can come from anywhere and this group should be heard just as any and every other resident and community group should be.

Log in to reply

Journey

1:42 pm on Monday, May 24, 2010

Not the gazebo, the play structure just east of the gazebo. The older wooden and plastic thing.

Log in to reply

Journey

1:43 pm on Monday, May 24, 2010

opps... The hopes are to replace old play stuctures with rotting wood with newer ones.

Log in to reply
Comment_arrow

FAP

2:49 pm on Monday, May 24, 2010

Gotcha. I first thought you meant the center of the park. Thanks for the calification.

Comment_arrow

randyrandy

5:00 pm on Sunday, May 30, 2010

the structures in CSP are not made of wood!

Scott M. Siegel

4:49 pm on Monday, May 24, 2010

Accurate article. I was initially skeptical but the Play women were clear that they would not alter the existing footprint, only upgrade the equipment. It's not their fault that the park is a mess while trying to accommodate everyone. I too wish it was more open, but it isn't their fault.

Log in to reply

randyrandy

9:19 pm on Tuesday, May 25, 2010

'bout time someone told Tumpson and the ladies to shut up!
Isn't Fallick a Rent Control Trustee ( a public official)?
Act accordingly

Log in to reply

hullabaloo

10:37 am on Friday, May 28, 2010

I love the irony of Ondrejka complaining that the proposed swings are not being designed with adults in mind, "Ondrejka declared that she likes to use the swings at Church Square Park and that she's not the only adult who uses them. "That design is not good for adults," said Ondrejka, gesturing toward Project Play's swing set diagram." Isn't this the same Ondrejka who thinks the park should not be a playground?

Da Horsey has a great video of her opinion as expressed to City Council which should not be missed:
http://hobokenhorse.blogspot.com/2010/05/dust-up-on-church-square-park.html

Log in to reply

Journey

12:11 pm on Friday, May 28, 2010

I was there too and if you talk to people in person and try to understand their point of view none of them are that unreasonable.

Mary also pointed out that teens use the swings. I sit on the swing with my toddler in my lap. So that is an adults weight plus the weight of a child.

I'm sure we would like swings that an engineer has said can bare a reasonable amount of weight Otherwise the city will get sued when there is an accident caused by someone that weighs more than the swings can bare uses it.

Log in to reply

Reformerus_Gianticus

2:13 pm on Friday, May 28, 2010

I will volunteer to be a test subject for any Adult-sized swing. At 325 pounds, if the swing can hold me it probably can hold just about anybody.

Log in to reply
Comment_arrow

Journey

2:27 pm on Friday, May 28, 2010

Thanks for the laugh. I needed it. Just found out a friend died last night.

p1ywood

7:47 pm on Friday, May 28, 2010

Is there anywhere online to see an overview of the proposed layout?

Log in to reply

randyrandy

5:59 am on Saturday, May 29, 2010

Heard Lane Bajardi attacked Dog Owners at this meeting demanding they start paying to use the dog run!
If that's true, it seems Bajardi hates puppies too!
Odd coming from an attack dog like him...

Log in to reply

Journey

8:05 am on Saturday, May 29, 2010

Lane is not against dogs, he is against parents providing private funding if the dog runs are maintained by city funds.

Log in to reply
Comment_arrow

randyrandy

8:41 am on Saturday, May 29, 2010

That's ridiculous! Bajardi was just attacking because Cunningham owns dogs.
What about people who DON NOT HAVE KIDS PAYING FOR KIDS PLAYGROUND EQUIPMENT?
And FYI Journey, Dog owners pay annual fees AND TAXES to the city to license their dogs do parents pay a fee for kid licenses? NO
If a childless person pays school taxes, dog haters like Bajardi can pay for a crappy dog run -which keeps dogs off the streets.

Comment_arrow

randyrandy

8:43 am on Saturday, May 29, 2010

Journey/ Apologist
The private funding is optional participation, The City is not making parents pay, the parents took positive initiative to help their community-unlike Mason's attack dog.

Journey

8:12 am on Saturday, May 29, 2010

I don't know but the email for women who gave the presentation is hobokenprojectplay at gmail dot com.

Log in to reply

Journey

9:21 pm on Saturday, May 29, 2010

RandyRandy,

I'm going to address you once.

You like Lane would rather tear a community apart than to form coalitions between people that want to make the city better.

I was there were you?

Lane might love or hate dogs, but his purposed seemed to be get folks angry. I said just summarized accurately what he said.

I expressed no opinion on what he said, unlike you.

And lastly, thanks for being a real jerk after I mentioned a friend died. Nice, real classy.

Log in to reply

randyrandy

1:10 pm on Sunday, May 30, 2010

Uh.. are you serious?
First of all, nobody is tearing anything apart.
Second, your friend died, if true, my sympathies
Thirdly, Your friend dies and you are on here blogging? WTF -your authenticity seems a bit artificial.
Finally, how good a friend if you use them as a cover from criticisms?
Do you really think that gets you sympathy? Go spend time with your "friends family" or grieve said friend with the dignity your "friend" deserves. Not on here exploiting the death!

Log in to reply

Journey

1:49 pm on Sunday, May 30, 2010

I was checking my email, news of my family, news of his, etc. And there was the update for the patch and your messages.

Criticism should provide more than an attack. It should provide a path to grow by.

Now I'm off to find out how to stop getting up dates in my email so I don't see any thing you write.

Then to his facebook wall where friends and family of his are sharing memories.

Log in to reply

randyrandy

5:01 pm on Sunday, May 30, 2010

Gimme a break...
How does one grow by your posts?

Log in to reply

Journey

1:19 pm on Friday, June 11, 2010

Randy

People can grow (learn) through the exchange of ideas.

I mentioned the death of my friend before you criticized me. Before you chimed in about Lane and hating dogs. So to claim I made it up to get you to stop picking on me is incorrect.

You called me an apologist. You assume, wrongly that I'm some fan of Lane's. I was at the meeting, I heard him speak first hand, not 2nd hand like you. I was trying to give more context to his statements, not support them.

The more people with different interests fight each other the more the park will be torn up by politicians trying to please one group or the other.

If the parents, dog owners, singles wanting to sun bath, folks playing basketball in the courts, and seniors wanting to enjoy the beauty of the park all work together we might end up reversing the fracturing of the park.

The last thing we need is politicians or political operatives vying for votes by pitting different voting blocks against each other.

Log in to reply

Journey

1:23 pm on Friday, June 11, 2010

I should not have to prove my statements to you,but I will. I say this not merely to prove that someone died, but because writing about him feels good.

Alexei Kondratiev, a brillant and wonderful man, left this world. I was one of his Welsh language students at St. David's Society. He will be missed by many people who all feel thankful that we got to know him. Even the people that disagreed with him about Celtic studies expressed their respect for him.

I will remember him through actions, by continuing to learn Welsh, by learning and teaching my daughter how to identify birds and birdsong. My fighting to ensure that the parks are not just for the running around of children, but for everyone.

Google Alexei if you don't believe me.

Log in to reply

Journey

1:25 pm on Friday, June 11, 2010

Randy,

You are right no play structure is made entirely of wood. But the older ones are made of combination of materials including wood (some of which that is rotting).

Log in to reply

Leave a comment

 

The Hoboken Patch
Valentine's Shopping Guide

See the full guide!

Patch Picks